Obtaining Patient Feedback on How Disposable Medical Garments Affect Care Experiences
HeartSnug developed a medical garment designed to improve comfort, privacy, and support for patients, particularly women, undergoing cardiac diagnostic procedures. While early development relied on informal feedback from clinicians and patients, the company later introduced structured forms of feedback to more accurately capture patient experiences and refine fit, product design, and usability based on real-world use.
Quick Facts Organization name: HeartSnug |
Product Type(s)
medical device:
- other: patient comfort and privacy
Product Medical Specialty Area(s)
- anesthesiology
- cardiovascular
- general and plastic surgery
- general hospital
- immunology
- obstetrical and gynecological
- orthopedic
- physical medicine
- radiology
Stakeholders
- medtech company: internal discovery/research and development teams
- providers (clinicians, hospital/health system administrators)
Barriers or Obstacles Encountered
- budget/financial constraints
- timeline restrictions
- insufficient infrastructure
- challenges with reaching appropriate patient populations
Limitations to Patient Engagement Activities
Key challenges included budget and timeline constraints typical of an early-stage medical device company, which limited the ability to conduct larger clinical studies and formal patient engagement activities. The team also faced infrastructure limitations, including the lack of established research partnerships and systems for collecting patient-reported outcomes. Perhaps most significantly, there were challenges in reaching appropriate patient populations, as access to women undergoing cardiac stress testing and rehabilitation was largely dependent on relationships with individual health-care providers and institutions.
These factors delayed the collection of both clinical performance data and patient experience data needed to support product validation, evidence generation, and future development efforts.
Additional barriers to patient engagement included a lack of access and credentials at hospitals and clinics to conduct trials for its chest coverage garment on women undergoing cardiac stress tests.
Impact of Pursuing Limited, Absent, or Late Patient Engagement
The limited engagement of patients and patient advocacy groups during the early stages of development resulted in significant gaps in both clinical and experiential data. While the HeartSnug team received consistent anecdotal feedback from patients, clinicians, and caregivers indicating that the garment improved comfort, support, and confidence during cardiac stress testing, there was no structured mechanism in place to systematically collect, analyze, and validate these observations.
As a result, the company lacked sufficient evidence to support a formal proof of concept demonstrating that the use of a medical chest garment during cardiac stress tests could improve patient comfort, reduce anxiety, and potentially enhance performance during testing. Equally important, limited patient access prevented the collection of patient-reported outcome data that could have provided valuable insights into the lived experience of women undergoing cardiac diagnostic procedures. This included information related to physical comfort, feelings of modesty and dignity, perceived support during exercise, willingness to complete testing, and overall satisfaction with the testing experience.
Without early patient engagement, the development team had to rely largely on informal observations rather than structured patient feedback, delaying the ability to quantify the product's impact and identify the outcomes most meaningful to patients. Subsequent patient surveys confirmed many of the benefits that had been observed anecdotally and provided important evidence regarding user experience. Earlier engagement with patients would likely have accelerated data collection, strengthened the evidence base supporting the device, and informed both product development and clinical evaluation efforts.
Follow-On Corrective Actions
Future changes included partnering with a cardiac surgeon and her medical staff to trial the chest garment with patients undergoing cardiac diagnostic and rehabilitation procedures. To better understand the patient experience, the company developed a brief survey for both patients and clinical staff. The surveys collected information on comfort, fit, ease of use, perceived breast support during physical activity, feelings of modesty and confidence during testing, ease of donning and removal, and overall satisfaction with the product. Clinical staff were also asked to provide feedback regarding workflow integration, patient acceptance, and any observed impact on testing procedures.
The feedback confirmed that patients valued the additional support and comfort provided by the garment, particularly during treadmill-based stress testing and other activities involving movement. Patients also reported feeling more comfortable and less self-conscious during testing, highlighting factors that had not been fully appreciated during the initial product development process. Clinical feedback identified opportunities to simplify sizing guidance and improve instructions for use, helping patients achieve a more consistent fit.
The survey results were used to inform several aspects of product development and commercialization, including refinements to garment sizing and fit, updates to patient instructions and educational materials, and the development of provider-facing materials describing the intended use and potential benefits of the product. The findings also helped the company better understand which outcomes were most meaningful to patients, providing direction for future clinical evaluation efforts and supporting the broader evidence-generation strategy for the device.