Smartwatch with heart rate monitor icon on colorful diagonal striped background
Medtech Case Study

Academics and Patients Partner to Develop a New Cervical Orthosis

HeadUp Collar: Patient Cocreation Supports the Product Design of a New Cervical Orthosis
 

Source
The PFMD Book of Good Practices, Second Edition

Link
HeadUp Collar: Cocreation of a New Cervical Orthosis for Patients with Motor Neuron Disease/Neck Weakness
 

Description of Case Study

The HeadUp Collar initiative involved the cocreation of a cervical orthosis for individuals with motor neuron disease and other conditions that cause neck weakness and head drop. To develop a patient-centered solution, researchers partnered with patients and caregivers throughout the product development process, from identifying the clinical need and securing funding to codesigning, iteratively refining, and clinically evaluating the HeadUp Collar. Patient feedback informed multiple prototype iterations, selection of the final design for clinical evaluation, and ongoing product improvements, resulting in a commercially available cervical orthosis that better met patients’ needs related to function and comfort.
 

Quick Facts

Organization name: Sheffield Biomedical Research Centre
Organization type: academic or other nonprofit researcher
Product category: therapeutic device or technology
Region(s) of patient engagement activities: Europe: United Kingdom
Total product life cycle stage(s): discovery/preclinical; post-approval
surveillance/monitoring

 

Product Type(s)

medical device:

  • therapeutic device
     

Product Medical Specialty Area(s)

  • neurology
  • physical medicine
     

Stakeholders

  • patients and caregivers, patient organizations
  • investors (government, philanthropic, and private)
  • providers (clinicians, hospital/health system administrators)
  • other: academic and other nonprofit researchers
     

Methods and Sources of Patient Input

  • patient advisory boards
  • interviews/focus groups/surveys
  • human-centered design methodologies
  • patient-driven research agendas and investments
  • social media/online listening
  • other: workshops
     

Impact of Patient Engagement

  • Improved product design: Patient involvement was instrumental in shaping a cervical orthosis that better addressed the practical challenges associated with neck weakness and head drop. By drawing on patients’ lived experiences throughout development, the team was able to refine the collar’s design to improve comfort, appearance, functionality, and day-to-day usability compared with existing support options.
  • More fully addressing patient needs: The cocreation approach also helped ensure that priorities important to patients were considered alongside clinical requirements, resulting in a product that was more acceptable and usable in real-world settings. The case demonstrated how engaging patients as design partners can lead to innovations that more closely align with user needs and enhance adoption of assistive technologies.
  • Supported commercialization and product adoption: Continued patient involvement in media and communication activities following product launch increased awareness of the collar and generated increased inquiries from health-care providers and private customers.
  • Strengthened the business case for product development: Patient insights improved understanding of user requirements, supporting investment in the development of a competitive new cervical orthosis and contributing to new intellectual property generation through patient-driven research prioritization.
  • Supported continued product innovation: Patients continued providing ideas for additional improvements after the initial design, contributing to ongoing product refinement and dissemination activities.
     

Lessons Learned

The HeadUp Collar project demonstrated that patients can play a valuable role as codesigners, contributing insights that may not emerge through clinician or engineer perspectives alone. Engaging people with lived experience helped the development team better understand the practical, social, and functional challenges associated with using neck-support devices in everyday life.

The case also highlighted the importance of designing medical devices around outcomes that matter to users, such as comfort, appearance, and ease of use, in addition to clinical performance. By involving patients throughout development, the team was able to create a solution that more closely reflected real-world needs and preferences, increasing its potential usefulness and acceptability.

Additional lessons learned included:

  • Invest in patient engagement infrastructure: Maintaining an ongoing patient research advisory group provided an efficient mechanism for multiple research teams to access experienced patient partners and supported long-term codevelopment.
  • Build patient capability for engagement: Providing patient training opportunities and ensuring participants understood the project enabled meaningful contributions throughout development.
  • Maintain two-way communication and feedback: Regular meetings, ongoing updates, and showing participants how their feedback influenced prototype development reinforced meaningful partnership and sustained engagement.
  • Provide flexible and accessible participation options: Offering travel reimbursement and allowing communication by telephone, email, text messaging, and social media helped maintain meaningful patient participation over time.